These size 36 (women's 5) Pearl Izumi Select Road IV Cycling Shoes would be perfect for a Peloton bike. They're compatible with road or SPD pedal systems. The EVA foam and rubber heel bumper provide stability and comfort when off the bike. If you're Cinderella looking for cycling shoes in the Chicago area, please come try them on. If they fit you, they'd be a great shoe for the price.